At about 4.5 square miles, Kelleys Island is the largest U.S. island in Lake Erie, nearly twice as big as better-known Put-in-Bay, about 3 miles west. Put-in-Bay gets most of the attention – not all ...
KELLEYS ISLAND, Ohio - For a calmer, quieter island idyll, head north to Kelleys Island, larger and more laid-back than always-bustling Put-in-Bay. At 2,800 acres, Kelleys Island is nearly twice the ...