Jeremiah tells PEOPLE the day 1 couple "skipped a lot of steps" as he reveals what the final straw was for him in their relationship: "I really cared about her"

Cracks in their relationship began to show as Huda appeared controlling, overbearing, and even intimidating to bombshells who walked into the villa and wanted to get to know Jerem

Huda teamed up with Ace, who is Chelley's current beau, for the recent Love Island USA challenge. Following the challenge, Chelley expressed feeling betrayed and hurt by Huda. However, many fans seemed to be in Huda's corner, believing Chelley's anger towards Huda was unjustified.